Echoes from the Dawn of Humanity: Tracing Our Ancient Ancestors

Introduction: Whispers of the Dawn

Since the very beginning of its existence, humanity has sought to understand itself and its place in the universe. This quest extends far beyond a mere chronological historical narrative or a biological evolutionary journey; it is an intrinsic exploration into the profound philosophical dimensions of what it means to be human, and how consciousness, culture, and self have been shaped. This work, "Echoes from the Dawn of Humanity: Tracing Our Ancient Ancestors," aims to pursue these ancient traces, emphasizing that the past is not just a legacy, but a living whisper that shapes the present and the future.

A comprehensive understanding of humanity should not be limited solely to scientific or historical data. It necessitates a deep philosophical inquiry into the unique form of our existence, the nature of our consciousness, and our distinctive place within the vast fabric of being. This fundamental premise sets the thought-provoking and deeply reflective tone of the article. A nuanced discussion on the multifaceted nature of the term "human" will be initiated, distinguishing between Homo sapiens as a biological species and "insan" (the human being), a being intrinsically shaped by culture, meaning-making, and self-awareness. This distinction implicitly introduces the framework of philosophical anthropology that underpins the article's approach.

The primary objective of this article is to delve into the philosophical dimensions of our origins, meticulously examining how the behaviors, beliefs, and cognitive breakthroughs of our ancient ancestors echo in contemporary human experience, fundamentally shaping our collective and individual identities.

I. At the Threshold of Being: Biological and Philosophical Human

The Emergence of Homo Sapiens and Behavioral Modernity

The beginning of human history is marked by the appearance of anatomically Homo sapiens approximately 300,000 years ago. However, there is a striking time discrepancy: "behavioral modernity," characterized by complex technology and culture, emerged much later, around 50,000-65,000 years ago [1]. This significant time difference is a critical point that triggers philosophical questions about the nature and realization of human potential.

The concept of the "Great Leap" during this period is explained by sudden and dramatic developments indicating the full modernization of the human brain. This leap led to the rapid proliferation of advanced technologies such as bows, spear-throwers, fishhooks, ceramics, and sewing needles [1]. Concurrently, the emergence of sophisticated symbolic art forms like cave paintings, ivory goddesses, and music from bone flutes is considered evidence of the modern human brain's artistic ability and imagination [1].

Philosophical Anthropology Perspective

Philosophical anthropology stands out as a distinct discipline that seeks to understand the human being in essence, independently of specific cultural, linguistic, or social organizations. Its fundamental question is "What is human?" [2]. This discipline, instead of reducing humans to abstract concepts, deals with them in their concrete biopsychic totality, offering the possibility of evaluating existence in the totality of its conditions [3]. Unlike social anthropology, philosophical anthropology is more grounded in the foundations of philosophy itself and examines humans as humans [2]. Its aim is to pave the way for directly grasping humans with their unique characteristics, based on their concrete existential totality, their conditions of being, and the phenomena rooted in this totality [3]. Philosophical anthropology is inclined to present a theory formed with a very broad perspective, considering the viewpoints of other philosophical disciplines and not disregarding the natural sciences, thereby synthesizing the accumulated knowledge of these disciplines [2].

The "Beşer" and "İnsan" Distinction (Teoman Duralı)

Teoman Duralı's profound distinction between "beşer" (the human animal, referring to our biological and material existence) and "insan" (the human being, encompassing our spiritual, cultural, and intellectual dimensions) is a central concept for understanding the philosophical depth of human nature [4]. "Beşer" refers to the biological and material aspect, subject to the mechanisms of Darwinian evolution and primarily concerned with "mere life" (solely biological existence), shared with other living beings [4].

In contrast, "insan" is presented as a "super-beşer" dimension; it is associated with qualities such as consciousness, language, morality, art, freedom, and will [4]. Duralı argues that these qualities are not merely products of biological evolution, but rather have undergone "tekâmül"—a directed evolutionary process progressing towards perfection. He explicitly distinguishes this concept of "tekâmül" from the undirected nature of Darwinian evolution [4]. According to Duralı, this "insan" dimension is based on culture and revelation, and the fundamental factor transforming "beşer" into "insan" is morality, especially that stemming from religion [4].

Reason and Self-Consciousness

The concept of "reason" holds a significant place in philosophical thought as the defining characteristic that grants humans a unique and special position in the world. This idea, accepted by many philosophers from Aristotle to Hegel [2, 3], is directly linked to "self-consciousness." Self-consciousness is an inherent human quality that enables individuals to be aware of their own existence, engage in introspection, and possess a unique self-awareness [3].

The Great Leap Paradox and the Beşer-İnsan Distinction

Despite the emergence of anatomically Homo sapiens approximately 300,000 years ago, the "behavioral modernity" characterized by complex tools, symbolic art, and advanced cultural practices emerged much later, around 50,000 to 65,000 years ago [1], creating a striking time gap. If human development were viewed merely as a linear biological progression, this significant gap would be inexplicable. Teoman Duralı's distinction between "beşer" (the biological, evolutionary human animal) and "insan" (the cultural, spiritual, and self-aware human being) [4] offers a powerful philosophical framework to interpret this situation.

If "beşer" evolved biologically, then the "Great Leap" might signify the point at which Homo sapiens' biological hardware finally found its "software"—that is, the full realization of its "insan" potential. This realization might have been triggered not just by further biological maturation, but also by a profound shift in consciousness, the development of complex social structures, or new forms of collective interaction that unlocked previously latent cognitive and symbolic capacities. This suggests that the "dawn of humanity" was not a single biological event, but rather a prolonged, multifaceted awakening of the "insan" dimension.

This implies that "humanity" is not a static, predetermined biological state, but a continuous and dynamic process of "tekâmül" (spiritual and cultural development). The "Great Leap" was less about a new biological species and more about a qualitative transformation in how that species understood itself, interacted with its world, and created meaning. This ongoing process suggests that the "dawn of humanity" is not a closed chapter in a distant past, but rather a continuous unfolding of what it means to be human, where cultural and spiritual development are as critical as biological evolution.

II. The Birth of Symbols: Dawn of Culture

Early Hominid Innovations and Cognitive Shifts

One of the turning points in human evolution is the emergence of Homo habilis as the first tool-using species. This species is characterized by simple stone tool technology and increased manual dexterity [5]. The capacity for tool-making is directly linked to brain development and arose from existential necessities [6]. The technological progression from Oldowan to Acheulean demonstrates a gradual but significant increase in cognitive complexity and planning abilities [6].

The control of fire by Homo Erectus represents a profound cultural and psycho-social leap. Fire provided warmth, protection from predators, and the ability to cook food, impacting nutrition and brain development. More importantly, fire fostered new social dynamics among humans, allowing for gathering around a central point, facilitating communication, and accelerating psycho-social development [6, 7]. Even without fully developed spoken language, Homo Erectus is believed to have possessed a highly developed communication system to coordinate activities like hunting and maintain social cohesion [6].

The Emergence of Symbolic Thought and Language

Cave paintings, far from being merely decorative, serve as profound visual records of humanity's earliest expressions, offering a form of communication from millennia past [8]. These paintings are understood not as individual artistic endeavors, but as an integral part of a collective communication process [9].

There is new research suggesting a strong connection between cave art and the origins of language. The placement of paintings in acoustically "responsive spots" within caves implies a deliberate combination of auditory and visual art. This multimodal approach may have played a critical role in the development of symbolic thought and the complex, multilayered capacities of human language [9]. This unique combination of sound and image is considered a distinctive feature of human language [9].

From a philosophical perspective, images are paradoxical entities: while visually representing something, they also signify its absence or non-presence [8]. Humans are uniquely distinguished from other animals by their capacity to engage with images for their own sake, differentiating their symbolic function from their mimetic function [8]. This ability to produce and interpret images, defined as "homo pictor" (the painting human), is proposed as a defining philosophical characteristic of humanity [8].

Göbeklitepe: Cradle of Belief and Cosmic Awareness

Discovered in Şanlıurfa, and dating back to the Neolithic Age, some 12,000 years ago, Göbeklitepe stands as a monumental testament to early human belief systems. It is interpreted not merely as a settlement, but primarily as a cult center [10, 11]. Archaeological evidence points to a sophisticated ritual culture, including complex sacrificial ceremonies and the use of offering vessels [10].

The site is imbued with deep symbolic meanings, with intricate reliefs of animals such as snakes, foxes, and birds [10, 11]. The enigmatic "H" and "I" forms on the megaliths are theorized to represent males, females, and children, suggesting a complex understanding of lineage and procreation [10]. The precise alignment of the monumental pillars in a sequence of 12 implies an awareness of celestial cycles, indicative of a 12-month cycle. The central megaliths may symbolize the sun and moon, suggesting Göbeklitepe served as an early observatory, and its symbols may encode knowledge about Earth's rotation [10]. Specifically, stela 43 is believed to depict a significant meteor event [10].

Challenging prevailing patriarchal interpretations of Göbeklitepe, the text focuses on feminine principles, fertility, and the concept of "khôra" (a philosophical term referring to a receptive space or womb) [10]. The deliberate burial of the temple in the earth is interpreted as a powerful symbolic gesture, perhaps representing a hidden potential or sacred womb [10].

Co-evolution of Tool, Fire, and Symbolic Thought: Catalysts for "İnsan" Formation

Research reveals a clear progression in hominid development: Homo habilis initiating tool use [5, 6], followed by Homo Erectus developing fire control and sophisticated communication systems [6, 7]. Later, Homo sapiens exhibits a "Great Leap" towards "behavioral modernity," characterized by highly complex tools and sophisticated symbolic art [1]. From a philosophical anthropological perspective, "insan" is defined not merely by biology, but by culture, reason, and self-awareness [2, 3].

The capacity for tool-making [6] and fire control [7] not only provided survival advantages but also created new social environments (e.g., communities around fire [7]) and introduced new cognitive demands (planning, abstract thought for tool design). The emergence of symbolic art and its deep connection to language [9] signals a critical cognitive leap—the ability to represent, abstract, and communicate complex ideas beyond immediate sensory input. This transition from basic survival struggle to symbolic representation and shared meaning-making is where "beşer" truly began to manifest as "insan" and accelerated its "tekâmül."

These innovations were not isolated, linear developments but interconnected catalysts that profoundly reshaped human existence. Tools extended physical capabilities, fire enabled new social structures, psychological development, and a deeper interaction with the environment, and symbolic thought (manifesting in art and language) fundamentally transformed human consciousness. This allowed for the efficient transmission of complex information, the creation of shared realities, and the formation of complex cultural systems. This period marks a critical acceleration in the "tekâmül" of "insan," demonstrating that our unique trajectory extends beyond mere biological adaptation to encompass a rich, self-created cultural dimension.

III. Depths of the Collective Soul: Legacy and Echoes

Collective Consciousness and the Archetypal Mind

Collective consciousness is the sum total of shared beliefs, ideas, and moral attitudes that unify individuals within a society [12]. Carl Jung's profound contribution to psychology is the concept of the collective unconscious. This is a universal, inherited layer of the unconscious, shared by all humanity since the beginning of human history [13, 14, 15]. Within this collective unconscious reside archetypes—universal patterns, images, and symbols that emerge across different cultures and historical periods [14].

Archetypes are understood as accumulated responses and behavioral patterns developed by generations as they confronted fundamental human conditions (e.g., the universal fear of a lion, even without direct experience [14]). They serve to organize our perception and structure the content of our conscious mind [14]. While individual experiences and environment contribute to their manifestation, the basic anatomy and function of the human brain ensure the universality of these archetypal patterns [14]. Jung's concepts of the collective unconscious and archetypes offer a powerful psychological framework that complements Duralı's philosophical distinction between "beşer" and "insan" and the idea of "tekâmül." The collective unconscious represents the deep, shared spiritual and cognitive heritage that enables "insan" to transcend mere biological existence and engage in complex cultural development. It provides the fundamental "software" for the "tekâmül" process.

Ancient Rituals and Their Modern Echoes

Evidence from the Middle Paleolithic period, particularly from Neanderthal burial practices, points to the primitive development of abstract thought and a concept of death. These burials often included grave goods and the use of red ochre [6]. In the Upper Paleolithic, Homo sapiens sapiens displayed more conscious and elaborate burial traditions, involving artistic expressions and body adornments [6]. Furthermore, Paleolithic funeral ceremonies also served social and political functions, providing a platform for individuals to display their wealth and prestige [16].

Archaeological findings at Göbeklitepe provide compelling evidence of complex ritualistic behavior, including sacrifices, the presence of "offering bowls," and interpretations suggesting a "cult of the dead" [10, 11]. Parallels drawn with Dionysian cults suggest the possibility of ecstatic states and even human sacrifices in these ancient practices [10].

The article explores how many contemporary rituals, though sometimes perceived as "strange" or archaic [17], are in fact profound echoes of ancient human needs. These include the universal human desire for community, the marking of life transitions (birth, puberty, marriage), the celebration of humanity's connection with nature (harvest festivals), and the ongoing human effort to cope with the supernatural or unknown [18]. Specific examples of these enduring practices include the finger-cutting mourning ritual, the bullet ant initiation rite, tooth filing for aesthetic or spiritual reasons, and the practice of dancing with the dead [17].

The Enduring Power of Archetypes and Rituals as Humanity's Collective "Software"

Jung's concepts of the collective unconscious and archetypes [13, 14, 15] offer a profound psychological explanation for the remarkable consistency of certain patterns of thought, emotion, and behavior throughout human history and across diverse cultures. The emergence of complex rituals in the Paleolithic era [6, 16] and even pre-agricultural Göbeklitepe [10] indicates an inherent, deeply rooted human need to create meaning, impose order, and connect with forces beyond the purely material. These rituals—whether for death, fertility, cosmic observation, or social cohesion—were not arbitrary acts but expressions of universal human needs and fears, which Jung would argue are rooted in archetypal patterns. The continuation of seemingly "strange" modern rituals [17, 18] suggests that these ancient "programs" or "software" of the collective human experience are still deeply active, even if their outward forms have evolved. They serve as enduring mechanisms through which the "insan" aspect of our being expresses its fundamental need for meaning, belonging, transcendence, and a structured engagement with the cosmos.

This suggests that even behind modern rationality and technological advancement, humanity remains deeply influenced by ancient, often unconscious patterns of thought and behavior. Our collective memory, encoded in archetypes and continually expressed through various ritual forms, acts as a living, dynamic bridge to our ancient ancestors. Understanding these enduring echoes can offer profound insights into contemporary human behavior, the foundational structures of our societies, and the ongoing, often unarticulated, nature of our search for meaning in an increasingly complex world. This means that the "dawn of humanity" is not a closed historical chapter, but an active, continuing influence that shapes our present and future.

IV. The Burden and Gift of Being Human: A Continuous Inquiry

Humanity's Shared Heritage: Universal Qualities and Obligations

A core endeavor of philosophical anthropology is to identify and articulate universal human phenomena and achievements that transcend cultural and historical specificities [3, 19]. These include fundamental human endeavors such as the pursuit of knowledge, the development of science, the creation of art, the advancement of technology, the establishment of religious systems, and the formation of political states [19].

The philosophical idea that "humanity" is not merely a biological classification or a privilege, but also a profound responsibility and an intrinsic dignity, is deeply explored in this article. Humanity is presented as a fundamental obligation to impose meaning on experience, to create meaning in the world [20]. This deeply resonates with the philosophical understanding that human existence is a unique and demanding state of being. Drawing from Ernst Cassirer's philosophy, the article explores how humans uniquely construct a "symbolic universe" composed of language, myth, art, and religion [21]. This symbolic network is synonymous with the world of culture itself, empowering humans to build a distinctive intellectual and meaningful world [21]. Cassirer views human culture as a process of liberation; these symbolic forms are stages of self-realization [21].

The "Two-Worlded" Being: Nature and Culture

A central tenet of philosophical anthropology is the concept of humans as "two-worlded" beings. On one hand, we are products of nature—a realm we did not create. On the other hand, we are the architects of culture—a world entirely of our own making [4]. This intrinsic duality is a fundamental aspect of the human condition. The "beşer" aspect of humanity is undeniably part of the animal kingdom and subject to its laws; however, the "insan" aspect is described as "trans-evolutionary" [4]. This aligns with Duralı's argument that qualities like reason, morality, and consciousness cannot simply be reduced to biological evolution or fully explained by purely material processes [4].

Contemporary Echoes and Future Implications

The article touches upon contemporary challenges, particularly the concept of "herd mentality" within modern society, where individuals might experience a profound alienation from their own humanity [22]. This situation can be interpreted as a disconnection from the deeper "insan" aspect, due to an overemphasis on "beşer" (material, consumerist existence) at the cost of spiritual and cultural fulfillment. The enduring philosophical questions like "What is human?" [2] and humanity's continuous urge to create and find meaning [20] are powerful indicators of an intrinsic quest that has persisted since the dawn of humanity. This quest is not a historical remnant but a living, dynamic process.

The Tension Between Our "Beşer" and "İnsan" Selves: Enduring Impact in the Modern World

The article has meticulously laid out the "beşer-insan" duality [4] and traced the emergence of "insan" through significant cultural and symbolic leaps. It has also highlighted the profound, often unconscious, influence of archetypes and ritualistic impulses. The critical question now is: How do these ancient echoes manifest in our contemporary existence? The observation of "alienation" within modern "herd culture" [22] points to a profound imbalance or disconnection. If "insan" is fundamentally defined by consciousness, morality, culture, and the capacity for meaning-making [4], and if modern society often reduces individuals to mere biological or economic units ("beşer"), then this pervasive alienation can be interpreted as a direct consequence of neglecting our deeper "insan" heritage. The ongoing philosophical inquiry into "What is human?" [2, 21] is not a relic of the past, but a continuing testament to this unresolved tension within the human condition.

This suggests that the "dawn of humanity" is not just a historical period to be studied, but a fundamental existential state that continually challenges and defines us. Our ancient ancestors, through their struggles, innovations, and spiritual quests, laid the foundation for our complex "two-worlded" existence [4]. The "burden" of being human is to consciously navigate this inherent duality and to fulfill the "obligation" to create meaning in experience [20]. At the same time, the "gift" is our unique capacity for consciousness, creativity, and transcendence. Thus, the echoes from the dawn are not merely faint whispers from a forgotten past, but active, vital forces shaping our present challenges and future possibilities, compelling us to continually re-evaluate what an authentic and fulfilling human life entails.

Conclusion: Humanity from Dawn to Future

This philosophical journey encapsulates humanity's path from its biological origins to its complex, symbolic, and ritualistic existence today. The consistent philosophical lens applied throughout the journey has highlighted how each historical and evolutionary milestone illuminated deeper aspects of human existence.

The core theme that the "dawn of humanity" is not a static point in a distant past, but an ongoing, dynamic process of "tekâmül"—a continuous becoming—has been reiterated. The fundamental questions about being, meaning, and our place in the cosmos, first pondered by our ancient ancestors, remain profoundly relevant today and continue to shape our present and future.

The echoes from the dawn are not faint whispers from a forgotten past, but living, vibrant forces. They resonate in our collective unconscious, manifest in our cultural practices, and guide our individual search for meaning. Our ancient ancestors, through their struggles, innovations, and spiritual quests, shaped the very essence of what it means to be human, laying the groundwork for all subsequent human experience.

Our contemporary responsibility is to understand, acknowledge, and honor this profound heritage. It is our ongoing task to sustain the "tekâmül" of humanity, recognizing that the trajectory and ultimate destiny of humankind are intrinsically linked to the wisdom, questions, and enduring spirit inherited from its dawn.

References

• Akdemir, A., & Akarsu, B. (n.d.). Philosophy of Human. Ansiklopedi.tubitak.gov.tr. Retrieved from https://ansiklopedi.tubitak.gov.tr/ansiklopedi/insan_felsefesi

• Aktaş, E. J. (n.d.). Collective Consciousness: Anthropological Perspectives. Numedya24.com. Retrieved from https://www.numedya24.com/ercan-jan-aktas-yazdi-ocalanin-12-pkk-kongresine-gonderdigi-perspektif/

• Cave Paintings and the Origins of Language May Be Connected. (2018, April 1). Arkeofili.com. Retrieved from https://arkeofili.com/magara-resimleri-ve-dilin-kokenleri-arasinda-baglanti-olabilir/

• Derin, Ö. (2023, April 3). Göbeklitepe Philosophical Meaning. Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/2755820

• Do Cave Paintings Fall Within the Scope of Philosophy?. (n.d.). Sabahulkesi.com. Retrieved from https://www.sabahulkesi.com/2024/09/30/magara-resimleri-felsefenin-alanina-girer-mi/

• Duralı, T. (n.d.). Felsefi Antropoloji İnsan Nasıl İnsan Olamadı. Kitapyurdu.com. Retrieved from https://www.kitapyurdu.com/kitap/felsefi-antropoloji-insan-nasil-insan-olamadi/694730.html

• Evolution Theory in Ancient Greece. (n.d.). Evrimagaci.org. Retrieved from https://evrimagaci.org/antik-yunanda-evrim-teorisi-evrimin-temellerinin-ilk-olarak-yeserdigi-medeniyete-bir-bakis-203

• Fœssel, M. (n.d.). “Humanity means freedom. Period.”. Akademifr.com. Retrieved from https://akademifr.com/michael-foessel-insanlik-ozgurluk-demektir-nokta/

• Geertz, C. (1973). The interpretation of cultures. Basic Books. Retrieved from http://hypergeertz.jku.at/GeertzTexts/Kulturlerin%20Yorumlanmasi%20Geertz%202010.pdf

• Göbekli Tepe Figures Symbols. (n.d.). Kenanyelken.com. Retrieved from https://www.kenanyelken.com/gobekli-tepe-figurler-semboller

• Human Evolution. (n.d.). Holosen.org. Retrieved from https://holosen.org/insanin-evrimi/

• Human Evolution and Heritage: Philosophical Approaches. (2022, December). Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/3006058

• Hz. Muhammad and the Quran in the Light of Philosophical Anthropology. (n.d.). Bilimvegelecek.com.tr. Retrieved from https://bilimvegelecek.com.tr/index.php/2014/09/01/felsefi-antropolojinin-isiginda-hz-muhammed-ve-kuran-yayinlandi-peygambere-ve-kitaba-gercek-degerini-vermek/

• Instinctive Behavior. (n.d.). Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/340507

• Jung's Analytical Psychology. (n.d.). Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/809382

• Paleolithic Culture and Technology. (n.d.). Khan Academy. Retrieved from https://tr.khanacademy.org/humanities/world-history/world-history-beginnings/origin-humans-early-societies/a/paleolithic-culture-and-technology

• Paleolithic Period: Human Life and Thought Structure. (n.d.). Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/394121

• Paleolithic Savagery. (n.d.). Mku.edu.tr. Retrieved from http://www.mku.edu.tr/files/1024-2bf3cc28-1d3e-46a6-9b34-ea65769193f5.pptx

• Philosophical Anthropology: Conceptual Depth of the Dawn of Humanity. (n.d.). Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/794196

• Philosophical Anthropology: Origins of Human Nature. (n.d.). Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/1106369

• Prehistory. (n.d.). Wikipedia. Retrieved from https://tr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tarih_%C3%B6ncesi

• First Tools Human Cognitive Development. (n.d.). YouTube. Retrieved from https://m.youtube.com/shorts/EI0Eer_sku8

• Social Rituals from Primitive Societies to Modern Times. (n.d.). Gelenek.org. Retrieved from https://gelenek.org/ilkel-toplumlardan-modern-zamanlara-toplumsal-ritueller/

• Social Solidarity and Kinship. (n.d.). Site.ataaof.edu.tr. Retrieved from https://site.ataaof.edu.tr/pdf.aspx?du=LsNLZ7y/yQHqIcPSWMt0TQ==

• Sociology (Collective Unconscious). (n.d.). Mku.edu.tr. Retrieved from http://www.mku.edu.tr/files/1024-608b9991-4d0c-4fa4-a981-05fe73c4f8ec.pdf

• Socrates and Universal Reason. (n.d.). Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/188205

• Takiyettin Mengüşoğlu's Anthropology-Based Understanding of Human. (n.d.). Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/604096

• The Evolution of Human Emotions. (n.d.). Dergipark.org.tr. Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/794196

• The Humanization of Man and First Tools. (n.d.). Aktuelarkeoloji.com.tr. Retrieved from https://aktuelarkeoloji.com.tr/kategori/arkeoloji/insanin-insanlasmasi-ve-ilk-aletleri

• The Monster Heroes Within Us: Carl Gustav Jung's Archetypes in Evolutionary Psychology. (n.d.). Evrimagaci.org. Retrieved from https://evrimagaci.org/icimizdeki-canavar-kahramanlar-evrimsel-psikolojide-carl-gustav-jungun-arketipleri-8262

• The World's Strangest Rituals from Past to Present. (n.d.). Jaguar-kktc.com. Retrieved from https://www.jaguar-kktc.com/about-jaguar/jag-style/jag-life/gecmisten-gunumuze-uzanan-dunyanin-en-tuhaf-rituelleri

• When Did Humans Become Human?. (n.d.). Evrimagaci.org. Retrieved from https://evrimagaci.org/insan-ne-zaman-insan-oldu-13718